Do as I Say (and Not as I Do).

Reading his op-ed published in the Philadelphia Gay News and elsewhere, you'd think that National Gay & Lesbian Task Force head Matt Foreman was serious when he says:

First and foremost, everyone in the community, no matter where he or she is on marriage -- for, against, don't know or don't care -- must unite to fight the backlash. If we do not, we will lose. Period.

Second, because we cannot win this by ourselves, each of us must speak openly and directly to our families, friends, neighbors and co-workers.

Which raises, again, Foreman's decision to remain utterly silent on the marriage question last month when he took the podium at the 40th anniversary civil rights rally in front of the Lincoln Memorial, presumably out of deference to anti-gay black church leaders whose support he covets for NGLTF's broader left-liberal, big-government, income-redistributing agenda. (For more, see Rick Rosendall's column, "A March in the Wrong Direction," on this site.)

Throwing Stones at Arnold.

The San Francisco Chronicle's
story
about Arnold Schwarzenegger's 25-year old interview with the long-defunct "Oui" magazine shows gay activists of the left once again joined at the hip with their opposites in the religious right, who are also making hay over the interview. The Chronicle buries Schwarzenegger's full comments, which included a strong statement against stereotyping gays, while repeating the business over his long-ago sexcapades.

The paper quotes the big guy and provides responses as follows:

he referred to gay people as "fags," saying, "I have absolutely no hang-ups about the fag business; though it may bother some bodybuilders, it doesn't affect me at all." "

"I think he's got a problem, bordering on a fixation" about gays, said Assemblyman Mark Leno, D-San Francisco.

Michael Andraychak, president of Los Angeles' Stonewall Democratic Club, which opposes the recall, called on the actor to apologize, saying gays react to "fag" much as African Americans react to "the n-- word." "

Toni Broaddus, program director for Equality California, the statewide gay-rights group, said she was troubled by Schwarzenegger's description of group sex in the gym. "

Who knew that "queer" would become politically acceptable (at least among "progressives") but that "fags" would remain verboten? Or that gym sex would become a target of the lesbigay left?

What the young Schwarzenegger actually said, speaking in a language not his own, was this:

Asked whether he was "freaked out" by being in such close contact with guys at the gym, Schwarzenegger said, "Men shouldn't feel like fags just because they want to have nice-looking bodies...Gay people are fighting the same kind of stereotyping that bodybuilders are: People have certain misconceptions about them just as they do about us. Well, I have absolutely no hang-ups about the fag business..."

We report, you decide.

More Recent Postings

08/24/03 - 08/30/03

Let ‘Em Go.

An openly gay bishop is "The Last Straw," causing true believers to leave the liberal, secularized Episcopal church in disgust, declares Rev. Peter Mullen, the Anglican chaplain to the London Stock Exchange, writing in the Aug. 26th Wall Street Journal (online to WSJ subscribers only). He sermonizes:

Homosexual bishops? How long before we see pedophile bishops, necrophile Deans of Cathedrals and cannibalistic Archdeacons?

Nice, huh. The sooner these bigots splinter off, the better.

Not the Marrying Kind.

Gay historian James T. Sears has a column in the Washington Blade asking why gays would want to get married. His viewpoint is sexual liberationist, which is somewhat different from the feminist, anti-patriarchy/anti-marriage camp (and a bit more fun to read). He writes:

In our post-Stonewall struggle, we (particularly many gay leaders) have entered a Faustian bargain trading equal rights with heterosexuals in lieu of sexual liberation for all".[D]id those of us in the Stonewall generation riot to appear in the New York Times "Weddings/Celebrations"?

And he approvingly quotes from an early gay activist:

Harold Call, a prominent leader in the Mattachine Society, observed near the end of his life, "We are still operating under the anti-sexual taboo," he said. "The Puritan idea is Thou Shalt Not Feel Good. Unless you are miserable, overworked and under-f***ed you"re not really a productive member of the society."

But the vision of the endless orgasm will forever remain elusive (cf. Dr. Freud's "Civilization and Its Discontents"). Overwhelming, gays and lesbians want the right to marry and lead bourgeois lives, even if they don't choose to exercise that right -- at least while they're young and randy. And society benefits from the stability that spousal relationships tend to provide (which is the seed of truth that gives force to the pro-family camp's otherwise noxious propaganda about sexual anarchy). Sorry, but it's time to grow up, Peter Pan.

I'm not criticizing those who reject coupling up for themselves; it's certainly not best for everyone. But I'm critical of those who think it's not best for anyone.

Rally Speakers’ Shameful Silence on Marriage.

IGF contributing author Richard J. Rosendall watched last weekend's rally at the Lincoln Memorial marking the 40th anniversary Dr. King's 1963 March on Washington for civil rights. He reports that neither of the gay activists who spoke -- Matt Foreman of the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force, and Mandy Carter of Southerners on New Ground -- mentioned the fight to gain equal marriage rights for gays and lesbians, or efforts to build a coalition to oppose the anti-gay Federal Marriage Amendment. Their silence was presumably in deference to the rally organizers, who also chose to say nothing on the marriage rights question so as not to give offense to anti-gay black religious leaders.

Says Rick:

"Our relationships" was the closest Foreman came to mentioning marriage. It would have been comical if he had been explicit about how those awful Republicans are attacking gay marriage rights, as he stood a few feet from Walter Fauntroy, the favorite front man for the anti-gay Alliance for Marriage. How convenient for Foreman that it's all a simple partisan matter, and how pathetic that this would be seen by anyone as a serious voice of gay activism.

We'll be posting Rick's upcoming column on the rally shortly.

More Recent Postings

08/17/03 - 08/23/03

A March in the Wrong Direction

First published in an earlier version on August 22, 2003, in Letters from CAMP Rehoboth.

Forty years ago, when Bayard Rustin was organizing the 1963 March on Washington, his homosexuality was highly scandalous, so he took the title of "deputy director" to downplay his own importance. Yet Strom Thurmond still denounced him on the floor of the Senate as a communist, draft-dodger, and homosexual.

It was thus especially fitting when planners of the 40th Anniversary rally on August 23 in Washington reached out to the gay community. This year, The Human Rights Campaign, the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, and PFLAG were listed as conveners. Gay speakers Matt Foreman of NGLTF and Mandy Carter of Southerners on New Ground paid tribute to Rustin. Martin Luther King III said, "Homophobia has no place in the Beloved Community." That was nice, but what other messages were gays asked to endorse? The calls for unity and talk of "the cause" concealed the fact that many decent people do not agree with all the organizers' proposals.

The rally saw much talk of the Beloved Community, but it became clear that only progressive Democrats are welcome as residents. For example, Damu Smith of Black Voices for Peace attacked Condoleeza Rice, Clarence Thomas, Colin Powell, and affirmative action foe Ward Connerly, describing President Bush as "their master." Even as speakers condemned Republican demonizing of people, they committed the same offense. This reminded me of gays who condemn Bush's opposition to gay marriage while conveniently forgetting President Clinton's ads on Christian radio stations touting his signature on the Defense of Marriage Act.

The march's demands included no gay issues other than bills on hate crimes and job discrimination. It is odd that a fundamental issue like marriage, which is on everyone's lips and in all the news, was too hot for a civil rights march, while the official demands included normalizing relations with Cuba, opposing ROTC programs, and denouncing U.S. imperialism. If the marchers had time to adopt a foreign policy, surely they had time to defend gay families. But wait: one of the organizers, Rev. Walter Fauntroy, is a prominent supporter of the anti-gay Federal Marriage Amendment.

Several speakers attacked Bush's Middle East policies. Mahdi Bray of the Muslim American Society referred to "this modern-day Pharaoh on Pennsylvania Avenue." James Zogby of the Arab American Institute said, "We promised to liberate Iraq, but we brought them untold pain and chaos." He ignored the tyrant we defeated who gassed Kurds, tortured children, and filled mass graves.

Honoring Rustin and Martin Luther King, Jr. does not prevent us from thinking for ourselves. I shared King's opposition to the Vietnam War, and disagreed with Rustin's opposition to World War II. Sometimes defending freedom requires you to fight, as with terrorists and those who harbor them. Coretta Scott King, though a great friend of gay people, revealed hopeless naivete about the world when she said, "Non-violence must become the basis of America's foreign policy."

Just as all wars are not the same, non-violent resistance is not universally effective. It worked for Gandhi and King because the people of Britain and America truly believed that their nations stood for something better than the brutal suppression their news organizations reported. Had television cameras not been present at the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma, Alabama on March 7, 1965, the Bloody Sunday attacks by police against peaceful marchers would not have been seen by millions of Americans, and we would not have gotten the Voting Rights Act that year.

It does not honor King and Rustin to misapply their lessons or to use their memories as a political truncheon with which to beat up the current President for taking our national security problems seriously.

So while I appreciate the gay outreach, the protest still left me feeling like an outsider. And that was fine. The Mall sees many rallies, but moments of transcendence are few.

My own commemoration was late at night, when the crowds were gone and I could stand on the very spot at the Lincoln Memorial where Dr. King stood forty years ago and hear his majestic, ministerial cadences in my mind's ear: "It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal." Those words still challenge even civil rights workers.

Why Marriage Is Priority One

Originally published August 22, 2003, in The Washington Blade.

Whoa! Slow down there, homosexuals!

Yeah, we're enjoying a great gay run. For the first time ever, it's now legal everywhere in America for us to have sex with each other, and our relationships even got some validation from the U.S Supreme Court. Canada is poised to open up marriage to same-sex couples, and the stuffy Episcopal Church just confirmed its first openly gay bishop.

Even got pop culture is going gay: "Queer Eye for the Straight Guy" is the surprise summer TV hit. ABC's "20/20" has declared "it's in to be out" and the cultural arbiters at VH1 last week debuted "Totally Gay!" celebrating all things homosexual.

But let's get real. Gay marriage? In this country? Now? You better think twice about that.

America isn't ready for it. The polls show a backlash from the big pink wave that splashed over the country this summer. In fact, if you don't watch it, conservatives may succeed in amending the Constitution to ban gay marriages once and for all. Remember that's what happened in Hawaii and Alaska a few years ago.

You're better off winning victories incrementally. Focus on employment discrimination and hate crimes. The polling numbers are better and the visceral hostility from the public is not nearly so great.

That's the advice gay rights activists are getting these days from many gay-friendly public officials, and from gay contributors and activists as well.

Well, it's hogwash. And any leader of any gay rights organization who is not prepared to throw the bulk of their efforts right now into the fight for marriage is squandering resources and doesn't deserve the position. That's right; if they're not ready to make their top priority the freedom to marry, then they ought to resign today.

Impractical? How do you figure?

Consider for a moment how many gay Americans you know who have actually suffered from discrimination in the workplace? How many gay couples do you know who have been turned down from buying a house or renting an apartment because of their sexual orientation? How many were ever denied a room at a hotel or a seat in a restaurant because of homophobia?

How many people do you know who've been the victim of a hate crime where the perpetrator has gone unpunished?

Those people are out there, of course, and their stories are tragic.

Now multiply that number by 10 - or even 100, depending upon how broad your social circle is, and you've probably still not counted the number of gay people you know who've been discriminated against by this country's heterosexual-only marriage laws.

Between 90 and 95 percent of Americans get married at some point during their lives. If you carve out the homosexuals who can't get married (acknowledging that some of them were in heterosexual marriages before coming out of the closet) and that means that something approaching 100 percent of the people in this country who can legally say, "I do," in fact do.

The point is that no form of discrimination is more pervasive, or strikes more at the heart of being gay, than denying us the freedom to marry.

Still seem impractical? Consider this.

We are owed no right to work or buy homes free of anti-gay prejudice, and if we are bashed by homophobes, we have no inalienable right to demand that our perpetrators be given extra jail time because their crime was motivated by anti-gay animus.

These "civil rights" laws are add-ons; protections that make sense as good social policy and will no doubt dramatically impact people's lives.

But as social policy, they are often opposed on grounds that have nothing to do with homophobia. Employment and housing protections come at the cost of lawsuits, some of which will be frivolous. Hate crime laws do, at some level, punish thoughts, and pile on to an already Draconian criminal justice system.

None of these arguments wins the day, but they're reasonable and fair-minded; the same can't be said for those who oppose the freedom to marry. This isn't about protecting us from discrimination that might happen in the private sector. This is discrimination, perpetrated by our own government.

Once the government got into the business of issuing civil marriage certificates, and doling out (at last count) some 1,049 benefits and rights as a result of that piece of paper, there is no justification for slamming the door on committed same-sex couples.

As a result, the polls and politicians won't decide marriage, at least not initially. The courts will, and soon - not only in Canada but very soon in Massachusetts and New Jersey.

Should we forget about ENDA and hate crime laws? Of course not.

Introduce them both, hold hearings even, and watch them sit there, like the hapless "Bill" on the "Schoolhouse Rock" cartoon. That's been their sad fate for a decade now, no matter which party has controlled the Congress or the White House.

In fact, the best chance these two bills have for passage is a bruising fight over marriage. "Compassionate conservatives" and "moderate Democrats, " looking for some way out of the emotional tussle on gay marriage, are far more likely to vote for these baby-step measures.

But the real battle will be over marriage, and whether to amend the U.S. Constitution to ban them. It's a political fight we should win, if our organizations can work together, and our people will mobilize.

Early signs of that happening are mixed. Various gay groups are meeting in semi-secret "summits" to plan strategy, and hopefully from that will adopt highly visible and courageous campaigns to rally the people to accept civil marriage for gays.

Cutesy focus group strategies won't work here. Neither will the type of in-fighting and turf battles that all too often plague our movement.

We need rallies; we need marches; we need TV advertisements; we need speeches; we need pressure on "gay-friendly" politicians.

This is the big one: The fight we can and should win, and the one that really matters.

Bob Barr’s on Our Side (Gasp).

There's an important op-ed in Thursday's Washington Post by former Congressman Bob Barr of Georgia -- the author of the federal Defense of Marriage Act. It's titled Leave Marriage To the States. In the battle against efforts to amend the U.S. Constitution to deny same-sex couples any and all the civil benefits of marriage, Bob Barr has turned out to be an unexpected ally.

Barr, in fact, was something of a conservative libertarian suspicious of federal overreaching. He writes in his op-ed:

Make no mistake, I do not support same-sex marriages. But I also am a firm believer that the Constitution is no place for forcing social policies on states, especially in this case, where states must have the latitude to do as their citizens see fit.

However Barr's Defense of Marriage Act -- barring (as it were) the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages even if legally valid at the state level (as none were, or are, to date) -- was rightly seen among gays as an unfair denial of federal benefits such as a deceased spouse's Social Security, or tax-free inheritance of a spouse's estate. The overall effect was to treat our relationships as permanently "second class."

But the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment (FMA) is far worse, wiping out even state-level civil benefits for gay couples. You take your allies where you find them, and Barr's public opposition to the FMA should be welcomed and used.

Suddenly They’re Balanced?

Monday morning NPR reported (in roughly these words): "After the Lawrence decision, gay marriage has become a hot issue. Jerry Falwell has started a website to gather 1 million signatures against gay marriage. His site is www.onemanonewoman.org."

What's the point of making taxpayers pay for a left-wing radio network if it's going to shill for Jerry Falwell? Maybe it's budget time on Capitol Hill, and they have to show some balance.

Winning the Culture Wars.

From theagitator.com:

More Evidence that Conservatives have Well and Truly Lost the Culture War.

So I was channel-surfing last night and ran across the TBS Superstation Family Movie Night.

The movie? Victor/Victoria. I rest my case.

In response to this, someone else commented that they had recently seen the gay-themed movie "The Object of My Affection" run on another "family" channel. That, as they say, is progress.

Jesus Would Weep.

Sometimes it's revealing to see just how extreme anti-gay bigots in respectable places can be. A case in point is a sermon by the Rev. Steven R. Randall at St. Timothy's Episcopal Church in Catonsville, MD. As reprinted in the conservative Washington Times, the good reverend compares his fellow Episcopalians who support gay inclusion with the terrorists who destroyed the World Trade Center and took thousands of lives. From the pulpit, he intoned:

Like many of you, I feel like our church has been hijacked by misguided and in some cases evil terrorists. And like those planes of [September 11], our church is being used to destroy not only those inside in the name of some false god, but to destroy the lives of others, outside the church"

We've all seen the headlines of papers everywhere stating that the Episcopal Church voted to ordain an openly homosexual man... After that, the Episcopal Church actively supports the blessings of same-sex "marriages" as if they were holy and good and something from God. "

The current Episcopal Church will carry more people to hell than it will save. Our church is like a flying coffin.

Clearly, there is a Church of Love and a Church of Hate. It's pretty clear which church anti-gay Episcopalians like this jackbooted cleric belong to.

Recent Postings

08/10/03 - 08/16/03

Gay Marriage and the ‘Ick Factor’

It was the sort of headline that's become common these days: "When gays advance, America squirms."

I should be used to such headlines by now. When the U.S. Supreme Court struck down sodomy laws in June, we all knew there would be backlash. But I still find it rather unsettling, and this particular headline triggered my malaise full force. "When gays advance, America squirms."

Not "their opponents squirm." Not "some Americans squirm." AMERICA squirms. Suppressed premise: Gays are not real Americans.

Okay, so headlines need to be pithy. Unfortunately, the ensuing news feature on gay marriage underscored the message: gays are outsiders trying to move in. "Us" against "them."

But why? Giving marriage to gays doesn't mean taking it away from straights, any more than giving the vote to women meant taking it away from men, or letting blacks at the front of the bus meant that whites could no longer ride there.

Yet the latter analogy is instructive: when blacks moved to the front of the bus, many whites felt a visceral negative reaction, what some refer to as "the ick factor." Now gays are triggering the ick factor in their fight for marriage, and the results aren't pretty.

Some object to the comparison between the "behavioral" characteristic of sexual orientation and the "non-behavioral" characteristic of race.

But this objection misses the point. In both cases, there's a group whose behavior (moving to the front of the bus in the one case, pushing for marriage rights in the other) prompts hostility. In both cases, the hostility is largely visceral and inarticulate: "I can't explain it, it just FEELS wrong." And in both cases, the hostility results from, and contributes to, false beliefs about the group in question: "They're going to ruin everything for the rest of us!"

But how are gays going to "ruin" marriage? There are several possible interpretations of this charge:

1) "If gay marriage is permitted, people will choose it over heterosexual marriage."

This claim is, of course, ludicrous. After all, the usual response to a gay person is not, "No fair! How come he gets to be gay and I don't?!"

2) "Permitting gay marriage will cheapen heterosexual marriage by turning it into 'just another lifestyle choice.'"

Well, yes and no. Yes, it means that gay marriage will take its place alongside heterosexual marriage as an option to which persons might aspire. But again, these are GAY persons. It is not as if they would have, or should have, chosen heterosexual marriage otherwise. Let's face it: pressuring gays into heterosexual marriage is a bad idea for everyone involved.

Moreover, the fact that gays are fighting so hard for marriage rights should make it abundantly clear that they don't think of marriage as "just another lifestyle choice." Choosing to live in a high-rise instead of a ranch house is a "lifestyle choice." Choosing marriage is a major personal and social commitment. If gays didn't realize that, they wouldn't be fighting so hard for legal marriage rights.

3) "Gay marriages will be weak, setting a bad example for everyone else."

The idea here is that gay marriages will be less stable/monogamous/successful than their non-gay counterparts. Of course, it is difficult to substantiate this claim, since we do not know how gay relationships would fare given the same support that heterosexual marriage currently enjoys. But the more striking point is that on this logic, Hollywood actors ought not to be permitted to marry either.

4) "'Gay marriage' is an oxymoron."

The main argument against gay marriage seems to be definitional: the very meaning of marriage requires a man and a woman; thus gay marriage is a contradiction in terms. Gays who want to be called "married" are like steak-eaters who want to be called "vegetarians."

Thus understood, the argument betrays a fundamental confusion. The main issue is not whether gays should be "called" married. This is not to deny that words are important: they are. But the fight for marriage rights is not primarily about words. It is about legal protection for our relationships. It is about guaranteeing hospital visitation rights when a partner is sick, immigration rights when a partner is foreign, inheritance rights when a partner dies - and a host of other safeguards that married heterosexuals currently take for granted.

Steak-eaters are not vegetarians. But if steak-eaters were denied various legal protections that vegetarians routinely enjoyed, we could not justify such discrimination on the grounds that most vegetarians find steak-eating "icky." Absent better reasons, we would need to confront the ick-factor and work to make things right.

If the gay-marriage issue makes some Americans squirm, perhaps it's a sign of growing pains.

Episcopalian Independence?

Washington Post columnist Colbert I. King notes that some of the African Anglicans so vehemently opposed to blessing committed gay couples and ordaining openly gay bishops (and with whom anti-gay Episcopalians are now aligned) have defended polygamy in their own neck of the woods, arguing the need to show respect for African culture. Moreover, the Church of England mother church has an heir apparent to the pivotal role of "Defender of the Faith" who is an avowed adulterer (Prince Charles, of course). But gay couples and gay bishops are somehow beyond the pale.

The Empire Strikes Back.

Yes, the religious right is making its top priority passage of an anti-gay constitutional amendment to ban not only same-sex marriage but also same-sex civil unions, the Washington Post reports.The effort is led by "Christian family groups" such as James Dobson's Focus on the Family, which has more than 1,300 employees -- including 150 people who answer more than 15,000 calls and letters daily.

Coalition Politics (1).

New York Democratic State Senator Ruben Diaz Sr. of the Bronx has filed a lawsuit to block funding for New York City's Harvey Milk High School for gay (lesbian, bisexual, transgender ") students, reports the New York Times. Diaz claims the school discriminates against heterosexuals and takes money away from black and Hispanic students at other public schools.

Coalition Politics (2).

The big Aug. 23 rally at the Lincoln Memorial to commemorate the 1963 civil rights march on Washington led by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. has adopted a platform that endorses the federal Employee Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) and a federal hate crimes law, but is silent on supporting same-sex marriage rights or opposing the proposed anti-gay Federal Marriage Amendment. "This is a coalition march for jobs, peace and freedom," Atlanta gay activist Lynn Cothren told the Washington Blade. "This is not a gay march, although we've had involvement at every level."

But considering that past gay marches on Washington have devoted seemingly unlimited space to endorsing all aspects of the civil rights "social justice" agenda, including such un-gay related issues as support for race-based preferential treatment and opposition to welfare reform, might our national gay lobbies have expected just a wee bit more from the civil rights establishment in return?

Recent Postings

08/10/03 - 08/16/03

Episcopalian Independence?

Washington Post columnist Colbert I. King notes that some of the African Anglicans so vehemently opposed to blessing committed gay couples and ordaining openly gay bishops (and with whom anti-gay Episcopalians are now aligned) have defended polygamy in their own neck of the woods, arguing the need to show respect for African culture. Moreover, the Church of England mother church has an heir apparent to the pivotal role of "Defender of the Faith" who is an avowed adulterer (Prince Charles, of course). But gay couples and gay bishops are somehow beyond the pale.

The Empire Strikes Back.

Yes, the religious right is making its top priority passage of an anti-gay constitutional amendment to ban not only same-sex marriage but also same-sex civil unions, the Washington Post reports.The effort is led by "Christian family groups" such as James Dobson's Focus on the Family, which has more than 1,300 employees -- including 150 people who answer more than 15,000 calls and letters daily.

Coalition Politics (1).

New York Democratic State Senator Ruben Diaz Sr. of the Bronx has filed a lawsuit to block funding for New York City's Harvey Milk High School for gay (lesbian, bisexual, transgender ") students, reports the New York Times. Diaz claims the school discriminates against heterosexuals and takes money away from black and Hispanic students at other public schools.

Coalition Politics (2).

The big Aug. 23 rally at the Lincoln Memorial to commemorate the 1963 civil rights march on Washington led by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. has adopted a platform that endorses the federal Employee Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) and a federal hate crimes law, but is silent on supporting same-sex marriage rights or opposing the proposed anti-gay Federal Marriage Amendment. "This is a coalition march for jobs, peace and freedom," Atlanta gay activist Lynn Cothren told the Washington Blade. "This is not a gay march, although we've had involvement at every level."

But considering that past gay marches on Washington have devoted seemingly unlimited space to endorsing all aspects of the civil rights "social justice" agenda, including such un-gay related issues as support for race-based preferential treatment and opposition to welfare reform, might our national gay lobbies have expected just a wee bit more from the civil rights establishment in return?

August 14, 2003

The Marriage Backlash

Why we must tread carefully at this historic juncture. According to a new Washington Post poll:

public acceptance of same-sex civil unions is falling. Fewer than 4 in 10 -- 37% -- of all Americans say they would support a law allowing gay men and lesbians to form civil unions that would provide some of the rights and legal protections of marriage.

That is a precipitous, 12-point drop in support found in a Gallup Organization survey that posed the question in identical terms in May, before the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a Texas law against sodomy and Justice Antonin Scalia argued in his dissent that the court was on a slippery slope toward legalizing gay marriage.

The number opposing religious ceremonies blessing same-sex couples is even greater, with three out of four against us. How strongly held is that sentiment: "Among Americans who attend church at least a few times a year, 47% said they would attend services elsewhere if their church blessed same-sex unions," according to the Post poll. There is nothing to calls this but what it is -- a reactionary but widespread backlash. And we'll have to work hard to try to prevent it ending up with passage of an anti-gay constitutional amendment barring any legal recognition of gay couples.

The new (yes, NEW!) articles posted at right are worthy additions to this dialogue.

Forget backlash: We're just another American family, convincingly argues columnist Craig Wilson in USA Today. But is straight America listening?