I was at a bar the other day when someone I'd just met shouted
at me across the table, asking me how long I've been writing my
column.
"Oh, 10 years," I shouted back.
He was startled. "I thought you were in your early 20s."
He meant it as a compliment, of course, more a reflection on
what I look like than on my intellectual maturity. My sister has
commented on it, too. She just turned 23 and the last time I saw
her, she looked me up and down and said, "You dress like my
friends."
But I've been thinking lately about what it means that I and my
mid-30s friends all look-and act-like our compatriots in our
20s.
Adam Sternbergh of New York magazine calls people like us
"grups": grown-ups, condensed. Grown-ups who refuse to grow up.
Grown-ups who aren't sure what, exactly, being grown-up means.
"This is an obituary for the generation gap," he wrote. "This
cohort is not interested in putting away childish things. They are
a generation or two of affluent, urban adults who are now happily
sailing through their 30s and 40s-and even 50s-clad in beat-up
sneakers and cashmere hoodies, content that they can enjoy all the
good parts of being a grown-up with none of the bad parts (dockers,
management seminars, indentured servitude at the local
Gymboree)."
We hang out in bars. We watch "Grey's Anatomy." We drink the
newest drinks and watch the coolest movies and listen to the same
music in the same iPods as the 25-year-old sitting next to us on
the train. Heck, we're probably dating the 25-year-old sitting next
to us on the train.
Adulthood is even more compressed for gay men and lesbians, I
think, because there are fewer of us and we tend to clump together
and we follow the general American trend of wanting to be younger
than we are instead of older. So instead of young lesbians and gay
men aspiring to be like their wise elders, the wise elders are
getting tattoos.
Is this a bad thing? Well, not really. People should be able to
wear and listen to what they want, right?
What struck me in the New York article was not the riffs on our
grupster clothes-I thought those were funny and true. What struck
me was this sentence: "For a grup, success isn't how many employees
you have but how much freedom you have to walk or boogie-board
away."
That sentence struck me because oh, that, that right there, is
the problem for so many of us in our 30s and 40s. We define success
as freedom. And freedom means no defined roles and an overabundance
of choices.
So we wake up in the morning and our choices include not just
what we're going to wear or make for dinner, but whether we're
going to quit today, whether we should move across country and take
up snowboarding, whether we should be single again or move in with
our girlfriend and whether we should go back to school and try
something completely new.
We grups are a people without a map. Especially we gay and
lesbian grups, who don't have the traditional heterosexual plan to
follow, who may not be asked by our families when we're going to
have kids or get married or settle down.
Even if we are settled down-even if we have kids-we likely don't
have a plan. Instead, we are literally unsettled, insecure in the
knowledge that we can leave anything at any time.
We chose this shedding of obligations and requirements because
it's how our generation defines freedom. We don't want to be the
company men or women. We don't want to be trapped in gender or
social roles. We don't want to be the person with a lifelong regret
that we had never tried to make it as a rock musician or a
novelist.
So we've immersed ourselves in youth culture-and not even our
own youth culture but the culture of the millennials (whose music,
admittedly, is very similar to the Gen X music that we played on
our Walkmans growing up). We have immersed ourselves in a youth
culture where, like in all youth cultures, the driving force is the
individual pursuit of our own passions, whatever passions those
happen to be at the moment.
This differentiates us, I suppose, from the "Greed-is-Good"
corporate types of the 1980s. If that's what being grown-up is, we
don't want it-and good for us.
But maybe it's time to define what being grown-up is for us
grups. Because pursuing our own passions seems to make us happy in
the short term but not content and secure in the long term. Many of
us are still looking for purpose. We're still trying to find our
way.
I suspect that this contentment will come when we start devoting
ourselves to our community-our communities-instead of the latest
band.
But until we solve the puzzle of who we're going to be when we
grow up, we'll continue being grups-dressing and acting like we're
in our 20s, as if seeming younger will give us more time to figure
life out.