Originally published May 9, 2003, in The Washington Blade
.
ON APRIL 19, the day before the notorious AP interview with
Senator Rick Santorum, R-Pa., appeared, the Salt Lake Tribune ran
an AP story featuring Senator Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, talking about
polygamy.
At a town meeting Hatch attended in southern Utah, the director
of an anti-polygamy group said that teenage girls in nearby Hildale
were forced into plural marriages, and he asked how children could
be raped and nothing was done about it. Hatch replied that of
course children should not be raped, but said, "I wouldn't throw
accusations around unless you know they're true." He went on, "I'm
not here to justify polygamy. All I can say is, I know people in
Hildale who are polygamists who are very fine people."
As the Church Lady would say, isn't that special? His disavowal
notwithstanding, Hatch sounded more concerned about the rights of
polygamists than about the plight of child brides. My point is not
to call the senator soft on child rape, but to observe that
politicians are influenced not just by religious beliefs (the
elders of Hatch's Mormon faith renounced polygamy more than a
century ago), but by calculations about voters. Senator Hatch has a
lot of polygamists for constituents.
With the initial outrage and jokes on Santorum having run their
course (Jay Leno, noting that the senator has a problem with gay
sex, said, "Maybe he's just not doing it right"), those of us who
wish to defend our privacy rights need to make political
calculations of our own.
A few weeks before the 1993 gay march on Washington, Congressman
Barney Frank, D-Mass., warned that gay cultural advances do not
automatically translate into success at the ballot box. Referring
to the upcoming march, he said that having a big party on the Mall
is fine, but it would be more effective for gays to spend the price
of first-class postage to mail letters to their senators and
representatives.
Santorum's "love the sinner, hate the sin" stance - he has
nothing against us, he just thinks we should be arrested if we act
on our feelings - remains hard to dismiss in the Republican party
because that party has a large, well-motivated constituency that
agrees with him. As Andrew Sullivan observes, "It's not that far
from saying that you have nothing against Jews, as long as they go
to Church each Sunday. (Which was, of course, the Catholic position
for a very long time.)"
When Senator Trent Lott, R-Miss., lamented the 1948 loss of
Strom Thurmond's racist presidential campaign, and when Congressman
Jim Moran, D-Va., blamed Jews for the war in Iraq, both men lost
their respective leadership positions because of respect for black
and Jewish citizens. Gays have made great strides politically, but
we are well short of the goal of making homophobia political
poison. In the last election, candidates from both major parties
used anti-gay tactics against their opponents.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., and White House
spokesman Ari Fleischer have publicly defended Santorum, not for
their stated reasons but because scapegoating gays is still largely
accepted in the GOP. Alas, moderate Republicans like Senators
Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, and Lincoln Chafee, R-R.I., who repudiated
Santorum's remarks, are rare outside New England. Republican
leaders may be out of step with the moderate voters they need to
win elections, but this must be proven on election day.
With all due respect to my fellow Democrats, who in general have
been much more welcoming to gays, the answer is not simply
partisan. Persuading and motivating voters is easier when you
appeal to, rather than attack, their own values. Santorum's
coercive worldview violates conservative principles of smaller
government. Crusading to impose one's religious beliefs on others
is distracting and spiritually corrupting. A governing majority for
gay rights can best be achieved by making the conservative case for
respecting gay families and not just the liberal one.
Democrats can try advancing gay equality by embracing
traditional values such as "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of
Happiness" and respecting rather than scorning Middle America.
Republicans, including my friends in Log Cabin who are fighting for
the soul of their party, need to convince more candidates and local
party organizations that catering to the fanaticism of the far
right will cost them more votes in the long run than it will gain
them.
In Pennsylvania as elsewhere, this means
working locally and statewide to promote winning alternatives to
the likes of Rick Santorum. The other side is working
too.