First published March 23, 2005, in the Chicago Free
Press.
Every few years someone on the far reaches of the political and
cultural left peeks out at the country and is dismayed to discover
that most gays and lesbians are "embracing the values and routines
of the American mainstream" and failing to carry out the supposed
transformative mandate of the original "gay liberation."
Never mind that the idea of openly gay and lesbian people
leading contented, ordinary lives amid their neighbors and
co-workers would seem pretty transformed to most of the early
leaders of gay liberation who lived in more repressive times.
This scandalizes the radical critics who then write books trying
to explain for others on the far left what went wrong and whom to
blame. The latest entry is Stanford University Prof. Paul
Robinson's brief Queer Wars: The New Gay Right and Its
Critics.
Robinson thinks "the emergence of gay conservatism as a
political and intellectual force is arguably the most important new
development in the gay world." Further, "the new conservatives have
exercised an influence on the gay movement far in excess of the
number of their actual converts." For Robinson this is something to
be explained and, if possible, countered.
Queer Wars examines books by four writers Robinson
alleges represent "the gay right" - blogger Andrew Sullivan, critic
Bruce Bawer, broadcaster/columnist Michelangelo Signorile and
former OutWeek publisher Gabriel Rotello - focusing on
three issues and equating the failure to simultaneously embrace all
three with "conservatism": the gay movement's supposed affiliation
with the political left, the liberation of gender variance and
liberated sexuality.
Then the book begins to fall apart.
Signorile and Rotello both turn out to be on the political left.
Bawer, a New Deal Democrat when writing A Place at the
Table, said virtually nothing about politics. Even Sullivan is
described as a "classical liberal" à la John Stuart Mill - so not
very conservative. For that matter, most gays you talk with are not
on the far left but prefer fiscally prudent Democrats or socially
liberal Republicans.
As for liberating gender variance, that seems to be a romantic
fiction early gay leftists tried to sell. None of Robinson's
writers endorse it, but then neither have most gay men, then or
now. The gay clone style of the 1970s - and leather even more - was
a clear rejection of the idea of gender deviance. Gay personal ads
almost always insist on masculine partners. So if most gay men are
"conservative" about gender, how are these writers discernibly
different?
On the third issue of liberated sexuality, political leftists
Signorile and Rotello turn out to be more conservative than the
"conservative" Sullivan. For them, as for many other gays, the AIDS
epidemic seems to have recommended a more cautious view. But likely
even without AIDS, as gays and the gay movement matured, more gay
men would have settled down anyway.
So Robinson offers supposed exemplars of "gay conservatism" who
don't exemplify his definition, and supposedly defining issues that
do not reliably differentiate "conservatives" from most gays. What
Robinson really seems to object to are mainstream gay attitudes and
writers who articulate those attitudes. But if Robinson thinks most
gays are actually "conservative," then he must think anyone who is
not a radical leftist is a conservative.
Just as Robinson's thesis falls apart, so does his mode of
explication. He says he intends to "identify the tensions, even
contradictions in their thinking." But contrary to Robinson, for
instance, Sullivan's sexual liberalism hardly contradicts his
mildly libertarian politics: they are parallel. Nor is it
contradictory for Bawer to note that sexual orientation is all that
gays have in common while opposing the idea that gay people are
nothing but their sexuality.
Worse yet, while failing to find contradictions in his
opponents, Robinson commits some whoppers of his own. First he says
Sullivan and Bawer are less interested in enlightening
right-wingers than in correcting leftists. Then he admits Bawer's
book "is as much an attack on conservative homophobes as on gay
radicals" and that Sullivan's book attempts to persuade
conservatives to "amend their views of homosexuality."
Likewise, first he says Larry Kramer is an ancestor of the gay
conservatives but later says he represents "the whole tradition of
gay radicalism." First he says the National Gay and Lesbian Task
Force is "mainstream" but later admits it is part of "the
institutional gay left." So was he not candid earlier?
Robinson clearly dislikes these writers. Writing a book about
them was "a challenge to my tolerance." He finds some of their
views "downright repugnant." He accuses them of being "grubby
advocates for their own material interest." He asserts that they
feel shame about homosexuality, feel "self-disgust and anxiety,"
are prudish, dislike sex or have low sex drives. And so forth.
The war over the word "queer" is over, Robinson says. "Queer"
lost. So did the concept. All Robinson can do now is draw a
mean-spirited caricature of the victors and make cheap personal
attacks. Ultimately, this is a badly confused and dishonest polemic
and no credit to the author - or the University of Chicago
Press.