A Theology for Gay Marriage

First published July 20, 2005, in the Chicago Free Press.

When gay activists argue the case for same-sex marriage they make sure to emphasize that they mean civil marriage. The right of various religious denominations to determine the criteria for their religious marriage ceremonies is rightly protected by the First Amendment.

But gays and lesbians who are religious may long for a ceremony that may feel more like the real "wedding," so they feel more fully, satisfyingly married. Although a few churches already offer religious ceremonies, most denominations still do not. They say that same-sex ceremonies are not consistent with their theology.

So we need a persuasive theology for gay marriage.

There is nothing arcane about theology. Theology is simply the way people try to use revered stories and writings, visions, insights, and their own ponderings to understand the nature and intentions of the god or gods they believe in.

Theology is by nature conservative. But just as existing theology conserves the insights and experiences of earlier religious leaders, so theology is, in the long run, influenced by the deeply felt and clearly expressed experience of people living today. And that includes experiencing the presence of loving relationships by gay and lesbian couples.

As the bishops of the Episcopal Church wrote in a presentation to the recent Anglican Consultative Council, "We believe that God has been opening our eyes to acts of God that we had not known how to see before. Members of the Episcopal Church have discerned holiness in same-sex relationships."

But even Christians in denominations less explicitly open to the concept of a continuing disclosure of a god's purpose (what John Henry Newman called "the economy") are not without resources to begin developing a theology for gay marriage. Here are just four of several possible lines of approach.

  1. Some Christian denominations place so much emphasis on procreative capacity as the key criterion for marriage that they almost seem to turn Christianity into a breeding cult. But early texts offer scant support for that view.
  2. The Apostle Paul urged Christians not to marry and if they were already married to act as if they were not married. Paul offered the "concession" that Christians could marry but mentioned only the excuse of assuaging strong sexual desire, not anything about having children (1 Cor. 7:6-8, 25-29).
  3. Some opponents of gay marriage claim the defining characteristic of marriage to be a "one flesh union" of man and wife, citing Genesis 2:24. But they ignore the fact that the bodies do not actually merge (it is a metaphor!) and they miss the broader meaning of "one flesh union."

    Paul, for instance, writes of sex with a prostitute, "Do you not know that he who joins himself to a prostitute becomes one body with her? For as it is written, 'The two shall become one'" (1 Cor. 6:16). So "one flesh union" refers to any kind of sexual penetration, not marital or procreative activity specifically.
  4. According to Paul, belief in Jesus as the Christ rendered all attributes of social status, nationality and gender irrelevant.
    Paul wrote:
  5. "Before faith came, we were confined under the law ... But now that faith has come we are no longer under a custodian. ... There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ" (Gal. 3:24-28).


  6. A more forthright and comprehensive dismissal of the relevance of gender for the religion of Christ could hardly be imagined.
  7. In an interesting new book about same-sex marriage, What God Has Joined Together?, David Myers and Letha Scanzoni point out that the Hebrew prophet Hosea has God liken his covenant with Israel to a betrothal: "I will betroth you to me for ever. ... I will betroth you to me in faithfulness" (Hos. 2:19-20).

    "Perhaps," Myers and Scanzoni write,

    "rather than thinking in terms of gender, we might instead consider the characteristics of that covenant .... justice, fairness, love, kindness, faithfulness and a revelation of God's personhood. ... If these characteristics define an ideal marriage, might two homosexual persons likewise form such a union? ... If we can think in those terms, might we ... accept these (same sex) covenantal relationships as indeed a joining of two persons by God?"

Gay marriage opponents will, of course, offer counter-texts and counter-arguments. And gay-supportive Christians can respond in turn, drawing on additional texts and arguments. That is how theology develops.

To take one example, anti-gay advocates will note "Paul's" apparent enthusiasm for childbearing in a Letter to Timothy (1 Tim 2:15, 5:14). But gay marriage supporters can point out that linguistic and historical analysis have shown that that letter was not written by Paul but by an impostor trying to use Paul's authority to promote his own beliefs 40 or 50 years after Paul's death. (See Werner Kuemmel, Introduction to the New Testament.)

So for gay Christians the project of developing a theology for same-sex religious marriage can be both exciting and enlightening.

A Hopeful Tale.

There's a moving story in the New York Times about "an unlikely alliance between Joe Tom Easley, a lawyer and well-known gay activist, and Robert Reilly, a Defense Department adviser reviled in gay circles for an article he once wrote calling homosexuality 'morally disordered,'" who cooperated to bring a disfigured and half-blinded Iraqi boy to the U.S. for cosmetic and eye surgery.

When people can connect on a human level beyond political polarization, small miracles can happen.

Share the Hate.

The Washington Post reports that recently in Middlebrook, Virginia:

someone broke into St. John's Reformed United Church of Christ. The perpetrator smashed a window of the fellowship room, then crawled in and set fire to a pew and the choir platform where the organist plays. The only clue to motive was anti-gay graffiti spray-painted on the red brick wall in the rear.

The arsonist's message - and ire - broke through a hodgepodge of poor spelling and abbreviations: "Gays lover," "Lesb hell," "UCC siners" and "Sinner."

Just five days before the attack, the General Synod of the United Church of Christ announced its endorsement of same-sex marriage, though its decision is not binding on individual churches.

In all likelihood, the church wsa attacked by gay-haters who took literally the rantings of the religious right. But certain other quarters are just as intolerant. The Post also reports that a prominent Washington, D.C., African-American pastor and civil rights activist, Willie F. Wilson, in a July 3 sermon:

warned that lesbianism is about "to take over our community" and asserted that one reason women become lesbians is because a "lot of the sisters [are] making more money than brothers." He went on to describe a gay sexual encounter in explicit and derogatory terms.

Wilson is the national executive director of the Millions More Movement, which is organizing a march on Washington in October to mark the 10th anniversary of the Million Man March. The Post states that "several leaders in the gay community said Wilson's remarks might set back efforts to make the new march inclusive." Well, I guess so. But "other march organizers appeared at the church to offer Wilson strong support."

In other words when push comes to shove, guess whose rights are dispensable.

More Recent Postings
7/10/05 - 7/16/05

Maybe in the Bizarro Universe.

I received the item below from a reader who doesn't want credit, so here it is as a guest commentary:

Does anyone still watch Showtime's Queer as Folk? Well, my partner and I do. One of the themes this (final) season is a statewide proposition that the friends are fighting. I guess it's to deny marriage rights, though they usually describe it as "it will take away all our rights."

I expect that kind of sloppiness, and the references to Nazis and "it's like Germany in the 1930s" are par for the course. But I was struck by the lawyer, Melanie, going door to door who said, "If we lose our rights, what's next? Old people will lose their Social Security?" A tenuous connection, I thought. And then it's been repeated two or three times that "some of the largest corporations are pouring millions into this." Melanie even emphasizes, "Not just rich conservatives, but corporations!"

That's the part that really gets my goat. Of course it's completely untrue (that is, it doesn't happen in real life). And I assume it just represents ignorance and kneejerk leftism on the part of the writers.

Actually, QAF (honored with a GLAAD media award for outstanding drama series) is so ludicrous on so many fronts that one becomes numb, but I sympathize with the reader. As I've noted previously, corporations have been at the forefront of advancing gay equality. According to an HRC report, 82% of Fortune 500 companies include sexual orientation in their nondiscrimination policies and 43% offer domestic partner health benefits - numbers that go up every year.

Moreover, Microsoft's recent flip-flop and re-flip-flop on supporting the Washington state anti-discrimination bill (they were for it, then neutral when pressed by the religious right, then re-endorsed it when pressed by gays) shows the risks corporate America faces from even appearing not to take a stand, rather than being an active antagonist to gay equality.

Similarly, the one corporation that most invokes gay ire is Texas-based ExxonMobile, because it's the one big oil company that does not specify a gay nondiscrimination policy and doesn't offer partner benefits, and the old Mobile did before the merger (Exxon never did). ExxonMobile claims its general policies cover all kinds of discrimination, and that's debatable. But they're hardly funding anti-gay initiatives!

This anti-gay site lists companies that support and oppose the "homosexual agenda." The most "anti-gay" are guilty of not offering diversity training, or rescinding partner benefits. Those are the worst.

HRC, Abortion & Us

In our mailbag, a reader asks our opinion on a recent message from the Human Rights Campaign stating that, regarding the open position on the Supreme Court:

if the nominee doesn't even have an explicitly anti-GLBT record, his or her record on other issues, like choice, will be important. Roe v. Wade and Lawrence v. Texas are legally intertwined so an end to Roe could very well mean an end to Lawrence and the promise that it holds for GLBT rights.

It's no surprise that long-time abortion activist Joe Solmonese, now HRC's top dog, would stress this linkage. (While head of the Emily's List PAC, Solmonese channeled funds to a senate candidate who supported amending the U.S. Constitution to ban gay marriage but was "pro-choice.") And the claim regarding Roe and Lawrence is not baseless. As noted in previous items, Justice Kennedy's majority decision struck down state sodomy laws on "privacy" grounds similar to Roe.

But as I've also said, sexual privacy isn't likely to be the lead argument in future cases fighting the Defense of Marriage Act, or Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Those cases will be based on whether equal protection under the law is extended to gay people, as it should be, and as Justice O'Connor argued when she supported overturning the Texas sodomy law on equal protection, not privacy, grounds.

So it may very well be that the Lawrence sodomy ruling is the only one that will trace its pedigree to Roe.

As there are certainly gay people who do not favor unrestricted taxpayer-funded partial-birth abortion on demand for minors without parental notification, and possibly even people of good will who don't favor abortion as birth control but hold no animus against gays and gay legal equality, HRC's tying abortion and gay rights tightly together seems to put the interest of the liberal-left Democratic coalition above that of gay people (who, to be frank, are the least likely cohort to need unrestrained abortion access for themselves).

On “Bisexuality,” Some Truths Must Not Be Spoken.

A New York Times story published July 5, "Straight, Gay or Lying? Bisexuality Revisited," refers to a forthcoming study on bisexuality in males conducted by Toronto and Chicago psychologists, who measured how men who described themselves as gay, bisexual, or heterosexual responded to erotic movies. Three-quarters of the bisexuals were aroused in the same pattern as the gay men. The article concludes that the study "casts doubt on whether true bisexuality exists, at least in men."

Note: The research was on sexual arousal, not behavior. No one disputes that many men who are aroused primarily by men can still manage to marry and father children. It just suggests that their primary sexual orientation is still homo. And, in fact, researchers have long recognized that female sexuality is far more fluid with regard to sexual orientation and bisexuality, while men tend overwhelming to be one way or the other (again, in terms of what they think about when they masturbate, to put it bluntly).

But all this flies in the face of the "lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender" mantra proclaimed by leading gay activists. The "LGBT" fixation came out of academic "queer" activism in the 80s, and woe be upon anyone today who challenges it. So, even though there is no organized male bisexual activist movement, our LGBT (or, chauvinistically, GLBT) activists are up in arms over the Times story. The National Gay & Lesbian Task Force issued a statement declaring:

We remain stunned that the New York Times Science section would carry such a shoddy, sensationalistic and downright insulting story. It - and the profoundly flawed 'study' it purports to cover - are laced with biased premises, misstatements and inaccuracies. It equates sexual orientation with sexual arousal, as supposedly measured by a crude device. . . It defames the truth in the lives and loves of millions of bisexual men. The Times should be ashamed.

The NGLTF also notes that it is working with "bisexual leaders and the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) to consider a coordinated response to the Times article." But interestingly, its "media contacts from the bi community" lists three women - and no "bisexual" men.

Update: Openly gay science writer Chandler Burr states in a letter to the Times:

Some gay and bisexual advocates are condemning "Straight, Gay or Lying?" regarding a study suggesting that bisexuality may not exist among human males - something those of us familiar with the scientific literature have known since, basically, forever.

Compare this hysterical - and anti-science - reaction to the conservative Christians' anti-science reaction to studies showing that homosexuality is an inborn orientation like left-handedness. They're identical.

The right hates science because the data contradict (in the case of homosexuality) Leviticus; the left because the data contradict the liberal lie that we're environment-created, not hard-wired in any way.

These particular scientific facts are making these advocates scream like members of the extreme right, though it's they who always tells the right to let go of concepts that are contradicted by science.

Dogma to the left, dogma to the right, and the facts be damned.

More Recent Postings
7/3/05 - 7/9/05

Of Bigots and Cowards—and Principled Independents.

Here's an interesting story out of Virginia, where independent gubernatorial candidate Russ Potts supports changing state law to let gays adopt, while both the Republican and Democratic candidates want to keep the adoption ban in place.

Potts is actually a Republican state senator (and chairman of the state senate's education and health committee) who, the AP reports, "is disenchanted with what he sees as his party's turn toward right-wing extremism on social issues." Moreover, "Potts said he saw no reason law-abiding gay couples who can provide good homes for children without parents should be barred from doing so."

The Republican nominee, Jerry Kilgore, flatly opposes adoptions by gays, but so does Democrat Tim Kaine, who says only married couples should be allowed to adopt (but, of course, he strongly opposes letting gays marry).

Many charge that anti-gay Republicans "force" Democrats in GOP-majority states to take anti-gay positions. While I don't think that excuses the Democrats' "see, we're bigots, too" stance, it does point out that the real battle for gay legal equality rests within the Republican party. Democrats won't be moved to embrace gay equality until it's "safe" for them to do so (i.e., it won't require them to spend too much political capital).

But until the time when pro-gay Republicans can wrest control of their party away from the religious right, I'm happy to see some break ranks and, like Potts, make independent runs for office.

Taking Gay Dollars for Granted.

Harry Reid, the U.S. Senate's Democratic leader, has suggested that four of his Republican colleagues be considered by President Bush as potential Supreme Court justices. Among Reid's recommendations: Florida Sen. Mel Martinez. "There are people who serve in the Senate now who are Republicans who I think would be outstanding Supreme Court members," Reid said.

Martinez is best remembered by gay voters for his rabidly homophobic slanders, which were the cornerstone of his election bid. He accused his opponent, conservative former GOP Congressman Bill McCollum, of being "the new darling of the homosexual extremists" and "anti-family," and of trying to appease "the radical homosexual lobby" because he supported a bipartisan federal hate-crimes bill that included sexual orientation.

Walter Olson notes that all four of Reid's recommendations are reliable allies of the trial lawyers' lobby, a key Democratic Party funding bloc. Olson writes, "while none of Sen. Reid's four faves are identified with the GOP's socially liberal Chafee-Snowe wing, all four. . .have repeatedly broken partisan ranks to side with the Democrats and the organized bar against liability reforms. "

Apparently, Reid is ok with a virulent homophobe (and maybe even a Roe v. Wade skeptic) as long as he'd be likely to keep the lawyers happy.

Sure looks like someone's taking HRC and its gay dollars for Democrats for granted.

Eyes on the Court.

This story on legal battles against the military's don't ask, don't tell policy suggests how important the next Supreme Court justice will be for hot-button gay issues. The Pentagon wants the challenges dismissed, saying that the Supreme Court's Lawrence ruling nullifying sodomy laws has no bearing on the case because the dismissed service members "could have abstain from sexual activity and not reveal their sexuality." The plaintiffs maintain that the current policy denied them the right of privacy, equal protection of the law and freedom of speech.

In Lawrence, the majority ruled that sodomy laws were an unconstitutional violation of privacy for gays and straights alike, while Justice O'Connor's concurring decision ruled against same-sex sodomy statutes as a violation of equal protection under the law for gays. As I've said before and others have reiterated in their comments on my earlier post about O'Connor, her take (though not embraced by the majority) remains by far the more valuable in fighting legal double-standards on marriage, the military, and other areas of state-sponsored discrimination.

Whether her replacement is a fair-minded, small government conservative like O'Connor, or a flaming bigot like Scalia, will make a huge difference in our lives for many years to come. Bush's assertion that abortion and gay marriage won't be "litmus test" issues offers at least some room for hope.

Luther Vandross’s Glass Closet

Luther Vandross was the avatar of romance. Other people's.

The famed R&B singer, who died last week at 54, zealously declined to discuss his personal life, telling reporters that it was "none of your damn business." Indeed, when his biographer Craig Seymour tried repeatedly to broach the subject of his sexuality, the singer told him, "You're trying to zero in on something that you are never ever gonna get....Look at you, just circling the airport. You ain't never gonna land."

Well, I'm just going to come out and say it. Vandross was gay.

Not that I've ever slept with him, or even know him personally. But his gayness was as much an open secret as Liberace's or Peter Allen's. And like those two similarly flamboyant and energetic performers, he was a master of hiding in plain sight, neither confirming nor denying what anyone with even moderately well-tuned gaydar knew anyway.

So Seymour's biography, Luther: The Life and Longing of Luther Vandross, dances around the question it can't quite ignore. As reviewer J.S. Hall described the book:

Any motions of love and/or romance are followed by the observation that Vandross has never revealed any of his beloveds' names or gender. And while they are not traits exclusive to gay men, Vandross's near-total immersion into his work, his fluctuating weight, his penchant for perfectionism (and his bitchiness when things don't live up to his expectations), his love of flashy stage clothes and the color pink, his flare for interior design and his ownership and display of a homoerotic David Hockney painting, all strongly suggest someone who's focused far too much time, energy and effort into submerging an aspect of himself that he doesn't wish to deal with.

Or at least, that he didn't wish to deal with publicly and directly. Instead, Vandross dropped hints, as when he retained the masculine pronouns in his 1994 recording of Roberta Flack's hit "Killing Me Softly": "I felt all flushed with fever, embarrassed by the crowd. I felt he'd found my letters and read each one out loud."

Such subtlety - some would say "evasiveness" - was consistent with Vandross's general approach: "I'm more into poetry and metaphor, and I would much rather imply something rather than to blatantly state it," he once told a reporter. "You blatantly state stuff sometimes when you can't think of a poetic way to say it."

True enough. But you also use poetry and metaphor sometimes when you're afraid or embarrassed to state things plainly. One can now only wonder at the full explanation for Vandross's legendary non-answers.

Perhaps one cannot blame the obituary-writers for being as elusive as Vandross on the subject of his sexuality. Most do not mention it at all, and the few that mention it do so only obliquely. The following, from the AP story, is typical: "The lifelong bachelor never had any children, but doted on his nieces and nephews. The entertainer said his busy lifestyle made marriage difficult; besides, it wasn't what he wanted."

Well, duh - unless "marriage" is read to include same-sex marriage. But most readers won't make that connection, and Vandross would presumably be just fine with that.

Some readers will no doubt think I'm being inappropriate. Perhaps you agree with Vandross that it's none of our damn business, and perhaps it isn't. But you can't fault me for pointing out that a celebrity who made a career out of singing about romance adopted a rigorous "Don't ask, don't tell" policy regarding his own. Even if his sexuality is none of our damn business, the irony of his public posture certainly is.

Or perhaps you'll insist that coming out is a personal choice. Of course it is. But it doesn't follow that we shouldn't encourage people to make that choice, or that if they don't we must be complicit in whatever public posture they assume, including those that treat gayness as a dirty little secret.

And this, ultimately, is what bothers me about hide-in-plain-sight gays: their implication that same-sex love is something unmentionable. As the philosopher Richard Mohr puts it:

People need to let the gayness of individuals come up where it is relevant, rather than going along with the shaming social convention of the closet, the demand that every gay person is bound to keep every other gay person's secret secret. For the closet is the site where anti-gay loathing and gay self-loathing mutually reinforce each other. Even people who are out of the closet demean themselves when they maintain other people's closets. For the closet's secret is a dirty little secret that degrades all people.

Luther Vandross was often rightly praised for the honesty of his music. If only he had taken that honesty one step further.