As laws protecting gay Americans from discrimination
proliferate, they increasingly conflict with important liberties.
The latest example of this clash comes from Massachusetts, where
Catholic Charities of Boston has decided to stop providing
adoption services rather than comply with a state law
prohibiting discrimination against gay couples.
Gov. Mitt Romney (R) has
proposed a special exemption from this law for religiously
affiliated adoption agencies; gay groups have responded that this
would amount to discrimination that places politics before the
interests of children. While Romney's motives may be self-serving
(he's thinking of running for the GOP presidential nomination), his
proposal is defensible on principle and sensible as a matter of
politics.
Private agencies contract with the state to provide adoption
services. The state pays them money and strictly regulates their
operations, including the criteria they use to find homes for
children. For the past 17 years, Massachusetts has prohibited such
agencies from discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation.
This means that Massachusetts adoption agencies may not refuse to
consider same-sex couples as adoptive parents.
This is sound public policy. First, gay couples can provide
children with very good homes. Indeed, research so far tends to
support the thesis that gay parents are comparable to similarly
situated straight parents. They're at least competent to raise
children.
Second, there's a shortage of good homes for children. In
Massachusetts alone, some 682 children now await adoption. It would
be cruel to shuffle them from foster home to foster home while
turning away perfectly good prospective parents simply because
they're gay.
Until recently, Catholic Charities coexisted peacefully with
this anti-discrimination policy. During the past two decades, the
group has placed 13 children (out of 720) with same-sex couples.
Last December, the 42-member lay board of the group voted
unanimously to continue the practice.
But there is a chill wind
blowing from the Vatican now on all subjects related to
homosexuality. The church hierarchy has evidently decided to root
out all internal manifestations of opposition to its longstanding
belief that homosexuality is "intrinsically disordered." Cardinal
Alfonso López Trujillo, Vatican head of the Pontifical Council for
the Family,
recently said that allowing gay couples to adopt children
"would destroy the child's future, it would be an act of moral
violence against the child." Catholic Charities is reluctantly
bowing to this pressure.
When Gov. Romney proposed a narrow exemption for religiously
affiliated adoption agencies, many gay groups
reacted angrily. "Denying children a loving and stable home
serves absolutely no higher purpose," said HRC's Joe Solmonese.
"These bishops are putting an ugly political agenda before the
needs of very vulnerable children. . . . What these bishops are
doing is shameful, wrong and has nothing to do whatsoever with
faith."
In most respects, this statement is wrong. Allowing an exemption
would not deny children loving and stable homes. They will get good
homes through Catholic Charities, just not good gay homes. Gay
couples could still adopt through dozens of other private agencies
or through the state child-welfare services department itself,
which places most adoptions in the state.
At most it could be argued that allowing Catholic Charities to
discriminate would make it very slightly more difficult for gay
couples to adopt (since one private agency would not be available
to them). If numerous other agencies also began barring gay
couples, a real difficulty might arise. But that problem is nowhere
in sight in Massachusetts.
While gay advocates may strongly disagree with church doctrine,
there's no basis for saying that the Catholic Church's objections
to gay adoptions have "nothing whatsoever to do with faith."
Exempting Catholic Charities would serve the "higher purpose" of
respecting the deep religious convictions of a major faith
tradition, without hurting children or appreciably affecting the
adoption prospects of gay parents. That is what we'd ordinarily a
call a win-win situation.
I don't think religious objectors should always be completely
exempt from anti-discrimination laws (such exemptions are not
constitutionally required). If, for religious reasons, a
large employer refused to hire gay people or a huge
apartment-complex owner refused to rent to gay couples, the harm
caused by their actions would potentially be great. It would
literally foreclose many important opportunities.
Exemptions to laws of general applicability inevitably raise
slippery-slope concerns. All kinds of exemptions exist in all kinds
of laws. Each is an invitation to slide down a slope, but we seem
to manage it. Title VII is understood to exempt the Catholic Church
from having to hire women priests, for example, but that hasn't
gutted employment-discrimination protection. There are particular
line-drawing problems about what would constitute a "religious"
exemption, but those problems aren't peculiar to this case.
If we can grant religious exemptions with little or no burden
placed on others, we should presumptively do so. Yes, this allows
people to discriminate in ways that seem irrational or even
invidious to many of us, but our resulting discomfort is an
acceptable price for living in a religiously pluralistic and free
society. When there are plenty of alternatives for those
discriminated against, continued objection to an exemption seems
pretty abstract and illiberal to me.
If we can't respect others' exercise of religious conscience in
a case where it costs us nothing to do so, can we really be said to
respect religious liberty in a meaningful way at all? In an age
when government regulation encroaches on every area of life, to say
that we can't make an exemption under circumstances like this is
really to say that religion has no place in the public square. I'm
not ready to say that.
If respect for liberal principle is not enough, there is also
political self-interest in magnanimity. Some opponents of gay
marriage have been using this episode to claim, "Aha! This proves
that gay marriage will erode religious freedom. Massachusetts has
had gay marriage just two years and already Catholics are being
forced out of adoptions."
The claim is unfounded, since the conflict here is based on an
anti-discrimination law that predates the recognition of gay
marriage in Massachusetts. But it is a potent political argument.
This episode may unnecessarily fuel not just the backlash against
gay marriage but the senseless and cruel drive in some states to
ban adoptions by gay parents altogether.
So let them discriminate, but don't let anyone forget what
they're doing.