New Attacks on Gay Marriage

About a month ago a group of self-described "LGBT and allied activists, scholars, educators, writers, artists, lawyers, journalists, and community organizers" issued a manifesto titled "Beyond Same-Sex Marriage" in which they demanded legal "recognition of diverse kinds of partnerships, households, kinship relationships and families" with "access to a flexible set of economic benefits and options regardless of sexual orientation, race, gender/gender identity, class, or citizenship status."

The signers consisted mostly of "no-names"--people you've never heard of--along with a couple of handfuls of known gay and lesbian (mostly lesbian) academics, activists, former activists, and hangers-on. Some of the signers are heterosexual; most seem to be long-term advocates of the post-Marxian socialist and deconstructionist left.

As witness: The manifesto avoids gay/lesbian issues but is replete with venerable left-wing demands--e.g., an end of funding of "militarism, policing, and prison construction." And it emphasizes "women's issues" such as more money for "decent housing, childcare, healthcare and reproductive services," etc.

All this is not so much beyond same-sex marriage, it is in a different universe entirely. All gay marriage proponents want is a change in one law to allow them equal treatment. Manifesto signers want free goodies for everybody, subsidized by taxpayers. In other words, this is nothing but the economic and cultural left's attempt to link itself to the gay marriage movement.

This little exercise in socio-economic splenetics would have sunk without a trace except that social conservatives publicized it widely as proving their contention that gay marriage was the first step in a scheme to undermine and destroy marriage. Polygamy is just around the corner, they shouted. And, they added triumphantly, the gay marriage movement has finally come out of the closet and admitted what its real goal is.

Oh, blarney! None of this has been secret, none of it is new from the far left and it offers no support to gay marriage. In fact, vigorous opposition to marriage--a "bourgeois" institution denounced by Marx as legalized prostitution--has long been a mainstay of the Marxian and feminist left. They have routinely denounced marriage, any marriage, as an oppressive "patriarchal" institution, although no one bothers to explain exactly what is patriarchal about the marriage of two men or two women.

For instance, manifesto signer Paula Ettelbrick has written and debated in opposition to marriage--and specifically gay marriage--for more than two decades. For her to sign a manifesto that indicates even openness to gay marriage, if only as a tactical feint, seems disingenuous. I suspect the same is true for many other signers. If I didn't know better I would think the signers were trying to disrupt and discredit the gay marriage movement. Come to think of it, I don't know better.

Despite this well-known background, right wing polemicists eagerly welcomed the manifesto as proof that gay marriage advocates were finally being candid about their "real" intention to destroy marriage. It is, in fact, an indication of the utter poverty of the argument against same-sex marriage that instead of arguing against it directly, the right wing has to immediately change the subject and point to other familial configurations as social dangers--polygamy, legalized incest, whatever.

Bluntly put, there are no cogent arguments against gay marriage. One of the most prolific opponents of gay marriage, Princeton professor Robert George, after repeatedly trying to develop and present just such arguments, has more or less admitted that. In a co-authored article with one Gerard Bradley, George states that male-female marriage has an "intrinsic value" that "cannot, strictly speaking, be demonstrated" and that "if the intrinsic value of (opposite sex) marriage ... is to be affirmed it has to be grasped in noninferential acts of understanding."

That is about as close to acknowledging defeat as you can get without explicitly saying so. What if George Wallace had said that the superiority of the white race could not be demonstrated but could be "grasped in noninferential acts of understanding"? Certainly there was a sizable constituency for just such a view, but undemonstrable "noninferential acts of understanding" are a poor basis for creating public policy in a secular civil society.

Then too, Robert George and his colleagues have never explained very well what it is about their own requirement of a male-female polarity for marriage that excludes polygamy. It is hard not to suspect that George keeps harping on polygamy as an imagined consequence of same-sex marriage to distract attention from the far more obvious opening to polygamy his own principle entails. I'm sure many fine polygamous Muslims would agree.

Parsing Polygamy

At Volokh.com, IGF contributor and lawyer David Link explains why, in legal terms, the differences between same-sex marriage are vast. SSM fits neatly within the existing legal framework of marriage; polygamy would require rethinking marriage law from top to bottom. "If the husband died, would the wives continue to be married to each other? Why or why not?...And every question like these leads to others." Could a wife divorce one other spouse but stay married to the others? Again, why or why not? How many spouses could contest a divorce? What about child custody? Who would be responsible for child support? Who would be liable for debt? The problem isn't just that the answers are unclear; it's that no answer makes more sense than any other, because no answer fits within today's concept of marriage. In that sense, polygamy is literally incoherent. Link concludes:

Polygamy would require a genuine rethinking of marriage. And its multiplicity truly does have the capacity to undermine marriage: psychologically, culturally and legally. In fact, polygamy offers exactly the kind of concrete danger to marriage as we know it that same-sex marriage opponents have only been able to insinuate.

Back-Door ‘Victory.’

The new Pension Protection Act the president just signed is a good law, ensuring that employers adequately fund traditional pensions if they offer them to workers, and improving the flexibility of 401(k)s. It's the sort of common-sense bill that usually goes down in partisan wrangling, but enough horse-trading was done to achieve a good measure of bipartisan support, despite vehement union opposition.

The Human Rights Campaign likes the bill, too, so we are in rare agreement. But it's interesting to note that HRC praises it because of a provision it supported that will allow anyone to inherit a 401(k) nest egg without immediately paying taxes on the windfall, a benefit that in the past was reserved for spouses.

HRC frames this as a victory for domestic partners, and it can be construed as such. But only in the sense that your cousin Joe, or your home health aide Bessie, or your best friend Ryan from college, can now be left your 401(k) without having to cash it out and pay taxes. In other words, a former benefit of marriage has now been made generally available to any non-spouse.

If we can't achieve spousal recognition for gay couples (either via marriage or federally recognized civil unions), then such "victories" may be the best we can do. And I don't want to suggest that this won't be helpful for gay partners (as well as for cousin Joe). It's just not the kind of "milestone in the ongoing fight for the rights of gay and lesbian couples" that makes me want to celebrate.

SteveS comments:

Where's the gay left and HRC on eliminating the estate tax? They're nowhere to be found because it cross-pressures their other positions and allegiences.

I've tried to get some HRC-type gay activists in Florida to bring pressure on Sen. Nelson to support repeal of the estate tax, pointing out the benefit that would mean for gay couples to pass along high-priced homes and other assets to the survivor tax free as hetero couples can. The thought had never ocurred to them and they figured that something must be wrong with it if they thought long and hard enough. Finally they said that they were opposed to incrementalism. Evidently they wanted the whole enchelada or nothing. A great example of being slaves to doctrine and group-think rather than working to achieve the achieveable.

Lesbian-Feminists Can’t Be Bigots?

The Michigan Womyn's Music Festival, one of the preeminent lesbian cultural gatherings, not only bans women who weren't born women (that is, male-to-female transgendered women), but in a new wrinkle, reports the New York Times, is also saying keep out to "transmen" who are either females transitioning to males or (increasingly) adopting male personas without genital reassignment. So now, the only ones welcome through the gates are "women born as women and living as women."

If any other group discriminated against the transgendered in so blatant a fashion, wouldn't the p.c. police be out in droves?

Frank Kameny’s Precious Legacy

Take a few minutes to visit a remarkable website, www.kamenypapers.org. Over a period spanning decades, Frank Kameny's courage and conviction probably did more for the cause of gay equality than any other single force in America. The Kameny project, led by Charles Francis and Bob Witeck, is working to safeguard his papers for posterity by archiving them at a major library. And what papers! This treasure trove of civil-rights source material spans 25 boxes of correspondence, legal documents, brochures, photos, memorabilia, even the original signs carried in the landmark Washington and Philadelphia pickets of 1965-68. The Kameny Project offers a taste of the riches online. (Check out the Congressman who writes Frank, "Please do not contaminate my mail with such filthy trash." All too typical.) Frank Kameny is very much alive and well, feisty as ever; let's hope this project to memorialize his legacy prospers.

Dale Carpenter vs. Robert George

Here's Dale Carpenter's take on Robert George. George seems to think that an argument against polygamy isn't "principled" unless it's his own argument, which turns out not to be an argument-just an assertion. Money quote:

Those of us who have been making a conservative case for gay marriage do so, fundamentally, because we believe in marriage. We do not want to see it harmed and we do not think that this reform means every proposed reform of marriage, including potentially harmful ones, must be accepted. Ironically, George and the Gang of 300 manifesto-writers agree that gay marriage means anything goes. I don't expect that George will hold to that position when gay marriage is actually recognized (indeed, he'll strongly resist the supposed slippery slope to polygamy then), but the damage he is doing now by making a tactical alliance with them and arguing the line cannot be held will not have been helpful.

More: Maggie Gallagher chimes in. Jonathan Rauch replies here.

First Amendment, Last in Our Hearts

A quick test of your commitment to the First Amendment is to ask yourself whether you support the American Civil Liberties Union in its lawsuit defending the right of the anti-gay Phelps clan to conduct its hateful demonstrations outside the funerals of American soldiers killed in Iraq. Many will answer no, saying something like, "I'm all for freedom of speech, but it has limits."

The same sentiment was widely uttered earlier this year after a Danish newspaper printed cartoons of the prophet Muhammad. Many commentators seriously asserted that no one has a right to offend other people's beliefs. Similar views are often expressed about protesters burning the American flag.

In the current session of the Washington D.C. city council, a bill to protect adolescents and children from the corrupting influence of violent or obscene video games was co-introduced by every council member but one. Its sponsors, including the openly gay chair of the committee with jurisdiction, were unmoved by the lack of evidence that viewing videos causes violent behavior, or by the fact that similar censorship laws elsewhere have consistently been overturned as unconstitutional. The lone dissenting council member, unsurprisingly, was also that body's leading civil libertarian. Fortunately, the council chair, now running for mayor, has heeded the city's attorney general on the bill's dubious constitutionality and withdrawn her support.

Recently, a draft rulemaking was published for implementation of the D.C. Human Rights Act's prohibition against discrimination based on "gender identity or expression." The local ACLU chapter and the Gay and Lesbian Activists Alliance (of which I am a member) raised First Amendment concerns about a provision declaring the use of certain words in the workplace as presumptive evidence of discrimination. ACLU cited the Supreme Court in Clark County School Dist. v. Breeden, which stated that "simple teasing, offhand comments, and isolated incidents (unless extremely serious) will not amount to discriminatory changes in the terms and conditions of employment." Rather than consider that perhaps the regulations should be tightened to withstand court scrutiny, the leader of the transgender activists expressed disappointment that anyone would raise First Amendment concerns, because "the First Amendment has often been used against us." Here was a member of a persecuted minority treating the keystone of American civil liberties as a hindrance.

In 2000, the ACLU was widely attacked for defending the free speech rights of the North American Man/Boy Love Association (NAMBLA). In response to the criticism, an ACLU statement noted that over the years it had represented such diverse clients as a fundamentalist Christian church, a Santerian church, Oliver North and the National Socialist Party, adding, "In spite of all that, the ACLU has never advocated Christianity, ritual animal sacrifice, trading arms for hostages or genocide. In representing NAMBLA today, our Massachusetts affiliate does not advocate sexual relationships between adults and children.

"What the ACLU does advocate is robust freedom of speech for everyone. The lawsuit involved here, were it to succeed, would strike at the heart of freedom of speech. The case is based on a shocking murder. But the lawsuit says the crime is the responsibility not of those who committed the murder, but of someone who posted vile material on the Internet. The principle is as simple as it is central to true freedom of speech: those who do wrong are responsible for what they do; those who speak about it are not."

I myself took part in the expulsion of NAMBLA and other pedophile groups from the International Lesbian and Gay Association in 1994, and toward that end I wrote a critique of NAMBLA that was printed in several gay papers. I used a copy of the NAMBLA Bulletin as the basis of my critique, which would have been impossible had it been censored by the government. Objectionable opinions are more effectively addressed by rebuttal than concealment.

As members of a minority group, LGBT people should be especially alert to censorship's two-edged sword. In her excellent book, Defending Pornography: Free Speech, Sex, and the Fight for Women's Rights, ACLU President Nadine Strossen points out that the anti-pornography campaign led by feminists Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin ended up being used against feminists themselves. After Canada, heeding the MacDworkinites, banned pornography that could be considered dehumanizing or degrading to women, Canadian officials began seizing shipments of books to gay and women's bookstores, including works by Dworkin herself.

Freedom of speech means nothing if not the right to offend, short of defamation and other narrowly drawn exceptions. In a 1943 Supreme Court ruling against forcing anyone to say or even stand for the Pledge of Allegiance, Justice Robert Jackson wrote, "Freedom to differ is not limited to things that do not matter much. That would be a mere shadow of freedom."

In 1820, Thomas Jefferson wrote of academic freedom at the University of Virginia, "This institution will be based on the illimitable freedom of the human mind. For here we are not afraid to follow the truth wherever it may lead, nor to tolerate any error so long as reason is free to combat it."

You should not seek liberties for yourself that you would deny to others. Sure, it takes more effort to refute something offensive than simply to say, "Shut up," but if we cannot make our case without silencing our critics, we are in trouble. There is no good substitute for persuasion, and there are no shortcuts to freedom.

There They Go Again.

Limited blogging through next week due to a family health situation. But I wanted to note Jonathan Rowe's take on the latest calumny from anti-gay crank Paul Cameron and his admirers in Christian-right media.

Unrelatedly, more signs that the Human Rights Campaign has abandoned any pretense of being nonpartisan, with its membership in America Votes, a coalition of the left that mobilizes voters for a full range of big-government, take-your-money schemes.

Not So Fast, Mr. George (2)

In his reply to my post, for which I thank him, Robert George fairly notes that many of the family radicals who signed "Beyond Marriage" favor SSM. Of course they do. But so do nearly all left-wing and queer-theory academics and activists, which is what these folks are. (With the exception of Chai Feldblum and a few others, they have not played prominent roles in the same-sex marriage fight. I mean, Cornel West? Gimme a break.) The important distinction is that SSM is only part of what these folks favor, and the rest is what they really care about. As the title of their manifesto proclaims, they are looking beyond same-sex marriage: they favor SSM, not as an end in itself, but as a way-station toward a post-marriage society in which all concepts of family enjoy equal status and marriage is irrelevant.

There's no denying that they speak for a prominent element of the gay-rights movement (not the gay marriage movement; there's a difference). I worry about their influence, as I do about that of socialized-medicine advocates and anti-globalists and gender-abolishers and other members of the ultra-egalitarian left, but I don't think they'll prevail, even within the gay universe, most of which is neither radical nor "queer."

There's a legitimate argument here about whether the culture will interpret gay marriage as "anything goes" or as "marriage goes." Actually, some of both may happen, but I expect the dominant vector to be reaffirmation of marriage's privileged status as the family structure of choice. Parents asking their gay kids, "So, you guys going to get married?", plus the longstanding social preference for the unique commitment of marriage (as expressed, for example, in corporate benefits reserved for married couples), plus the fact that most marrying gay couples marry precisely because they see marriage as a unique commitment - all these, I expect, will lead the culture to read SSM as a return to the values of marriage, not a further flight from them. The wind brings positive straws from Massachusetts, where a number of employers are revoking domestic-partner benefits now that SSM is legal.

In any case, it's hardly fair to saddle homosexuals with the burden of exclusion from marriage in hopes of preventing heterosexual folly. If straights insist on trashing marriage, it's not gays' job to stop them. Question: how many American heterosexuals would give up their own marriages to (maybe) forfend polygamy? Who would even consider asking them to do so? I'm often saddened by otherwise compassionate conservatives' willingness to think of gay people, in the SSM debate, as pawns to be manipulated for some larger social good. They must forgive us for declining to think of ourselves that way.

Regarding polygamy...OK, let me see if I get this. Polygamy destabilizes societies, is inconsistent with liberal democracy, shows pronounced inegalitarian and misogynistic tendencies, is frivolous by comparison to SSM, has no logical connection to SSM, and indeed is logically antithetical to the principle of SSM properly understood (everyone should have the opportunity to marry)...these are not principled arguments? Whereas "one man plus one woman makes baby" is not just a principled barrier to polygamy, it is the only principled barrier?

The problem, which is immediately obvious, is that "one man plus one woman makes baby" is no kind of barrier to polygamy, either logical or practical. Logically, man-plus-woman-makes-baby is a biological fact, but one-plus-one-makes-marriage in no way follows from it. Men are perfectly happy to marry all the women they can make babies with, as they have been wont to do since the dawn of history. Given that most human cultures have been polygamous (and quite a few still are), and that presumably all of these cultures have been well aware that heterosexual couples make babies, it seems self-evident that the man-woman-baby argument has little or no deterrent effect on polygamy.

A point of honest disagreement with George is this: in my opinion, the reasons to oppose polygamy are instrumental, not metaphysical, and all the stronger for that. And they are the same reasons for favoring gay marriage. Society and (generally) individuals are better off when everyone can marry and most people do.

That disagreement aside, I wish George would reconsider his strategy of pooh-poohing all the arguments against polygamy (and polyamory) that don't also militate against SSM - which is to say, virtually all the arguments against polygamy. Surely we could agree that this strategy does monogamy no favors. As SSM and gay partnerships gain acceptance, conservatives will be stuck with their own arguments that any change to the boundaries of marriage entails every change. It will be harder for the public, sensible though it is, to hold the line with conservatives insisting there is no line to hold. Sometimes I wonder if, like Col. Nicholson in "Bridge on the River Kwai," slippery-slope conservatives are forgetting what they're supposed to be defending. (Hint: not polygamy.)

As for polyamory, if by that George means group marriage, it might be different in some ways from polygamy, but it's analytically similar: frivolous, logically antithetical to SSM, and, to judge by the last several thousand years of experience, likely to devolve in the vast majority cases into polygamy. As for fending off formal recognition of non-marital polyamory (e.g., group cohabitation benefits), gay marriage is the surest method of preventing that.

In any case, it's well to remember that all this polygamy/polyamory talk amounts to changing the subject. Gay people are asking only for what straight people currently have: the opportunity to marry someone we choose (not anyone or everyone we choose). When straights get the right to marry two people, their mother, a dog, or a toaster, gay people will want the same opportunity. But not before.

Strange (and Brief) Bedfellows.

"Less than a week after becoming the 170th member of Congress to affirm that his office does not discriminate in its employment practices based on 'sexual orientation or gender identity and expression,' U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum, R-Pa., on Wednesday rescinded his signature on the diversity statement," gay.com reports.

Santorum's signature came after a meeting between the senator and GenderPAC volunteers, who got Santorum to pose for a picture with them (and just what must he have been thinking!). A copy of the senator's statement was faxed to GenderPAC on Aug. 1, and the signature was confirmed the next morning by Santorum's openly gay communications director, Robert Traynham.

But the next day, Santorum faxed GenderPAC a new statement that read in part, "To be clear, my office has not adopted the proposed 'diversity statement' nor the agenda of your organization. ... My name should no longer be reported as having adopted the 'diversity statement.' "

What happened? All too predictable criticism from Santorum's Christian right base, such as this missive from the Agape Press blog:

What does Rick Santorum have to gain by placing his John Hancock on this statement? ... why would Santorum sign a propaganda pledge that bestows legitimacy to a cause Santorum has long fought? Why bolster your opponents at a time when you have them on the ropes? Why let the enemy impose his will on you?

Thus even this obviously disingenuous political feint toward the center gets quashed by the Republican theocratic right.