I want to go behind the problem Steve calls out.
Activism loses the oxygen of victimization with every success, and eventually becomes indolent and tedious. The proposed boycott of Russian vodka (or, as Scott Shackford argues, “Russian” vodka) is the knee-jerk, conventional response of a gay rights movement that is settling into its golden years. It has little chance of doing anything, except possibly harming a fairly stable gay-rights supporter.
Vodka is a symbolic product, and the only value of a boycott is the calling of the boycott — which draws some attention to the problem.
There’s some value in that, but by focusing on this tired tactic, we are missing the bigger opportunity. Rather than attacking a company that is (supposedly) doing a harmful thing by providing financial support to Russia, or something, we should leverage some of the corporate successes we’ve had in the U.S. and around the world.
NBC will be the face of the American media in Sochi, and they have blandly, corporately told Chris Geidner that they’re all in favor of equality, of no specific sort.
So how about if NBC had an openly gay or lesbian co-anchor in Sochi? Neil Patrick Harris has conquered most of the other forms of entertainment spectacle, and this is exactly the kind of challenge he might be up for. Or Ellen, for color commentary. There’s no shortage of high profile, openly homosexual celebrities who I’m sure would make a fine addition to NBC’s coverage, including some (I’m sure) who are actual athletes. Or straight supporters who would have no problem mentioning a gay athlete’s husband, a lesbian producer’s wife, or some other innocuous fact that punctures the law’s fiction.
The Russian No Promo Homo law at issue is the kind of thing that only a country without a vibrant first amendment could even attempt, but that’s exactly the thing that a healthy corporate body like NBC could give the lie to. Russia’s law is the last gasp of the closet, and the number of ways NBC, or any other nation’s supportive media could ruffle Russian feathers is limited only by the creative ideas of those who are ready to mock it.
It is creativity that our activists seem to have lost. That is why the only idea that occurred to them was the boycott. We can do better than that.